Recorda’m la contrasenya
Un estudi de Chapin Information Services ha posat en dubte els sistemes que utilitzen els navegadors per a recordar les nostres contrasenyes.
Els resultats són els següents.:
- Firefox 3.0.4 i Opera 9.62 han superat 7 de les 21 proves
- IE 7.0 n’ha superat 5.
- Safari 3.2 i Chrome 1.0 només 2.
Trobo a faltar proves de l’IE6 que encara és un dels navegadors més
utilitzats. I per altra banda trobo estrany que tots els navegadors
fallin quan es posa Autocomplete=OFF, ja que jo ho he provat i funciona
bé en la gran majoria de navegadors, potser hi ha un truc o bé és un
error.
| Opera 9.62 | Firefox 3.0.4 | Internet Explorer 7.0 | Safari 3.2 | Google Chrome 1.0 | |
| Action Authority Checked on Retrieval |
PASSED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Authority Checked on Save |
FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Authority Raises Warnings |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Path Checked on Retrieval |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Path Checked on Save |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Scheme Checked on Retrieval |
PASSED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Scheme Checked on Save |
FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Scheme Raises Warnings |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Action Scheme Prevented if Unsafe |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Autocomplete=Off Prevents Form Fills |
FAILED | ? | FAILED | FAILED | PASSED |
| Invisiblility Prevents Form Fills |
PASSED | FAILED | PASSED | PASSED | FAILED |
| Method Checked on Retrieval |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | PASSED |
| Method Raises Warnings |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Multiple Paths Per User Per Authority |
FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Multiple Ports Per User Per Host |
FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Multi. Schemes Per User Per Authority |
FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Page Path Checked on Retrieval |
PASSED | FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Random Name Attr. Prevents Form Fills |
PASSED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED | FAILED |
| User Required for PW Retrieval |
PASSED | FAILED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED |
| User Required for PW Save |
FAILED | FAILED | PASSED | PASSED | FAILED |
| Valid URIs Don’t Break Anything |
PASSED | PASSED | PASSED | FAILED | FAILED |
| Totals | 7 | 7 | 5 | 2 | 2 |
Els detalls els podeu consultar aquí. En parla també en Xavier Caballe.
